Mineral Management  /  Royalty Audit & Management
Royalty Audit & Management

A royalty check shows what was paid. It does not show what was owed.

Operators calculate royalties from their own records of volumes, prices, deductions and decimals. Most owners have no practical way to check the result, so errors go unnoticed: a wrong decimal, a deduction the lease may not allow, a well that stopped paying, a balance held in suspense.

Warburg reviews royalty payments against production, pricing and lease terms, and follows up with operators when something does not reconcile. The aim is simple: to help owners avoid revenue lost to errors no one caught.

Request a Portfolio Review
FROM STATEMENT TO RECORD

An error that no one intended is still an error, and it repeats each month until someone checks.

Mineral ManagementRoyalty Audit & Management
  1. Overview
  2. Lease Review & Negotiation
  3. Ownership Verification
  4. Royalty Audit & Management
  5. Division Order Administration
  6. Portfolio Administration & Reporting
  7. Development & Activity Monitoring
  8. Generational & Estate Preparation
Why payments go wrong

Royalty statements are produced at scale, from records that change.

Royalty statements are produced at scale by operators paying thousands of owners. Errors are rarely deliberate. They come from records that were never updated, from decimals carried over after an operator acquisition, from deduction practices that do not match an individual lease, or from payments placed in suspense and never released.

Individually, the amounts can seem small. Across many wells and many years, they can be significant, and the longer they go unnoticed, the harder they are to correct.

EXHIBIT 1

One well, one month, reconciled

ILLUSTRATIVE · FICTIONAL DATA. Operator statement against what the lease and ownership record support.
Line itemBasisOperatorSupportedDifferenceStatus
Gas volume, McfSales volume12,40012,400—CONSISTENT
Price, $/McfRealized price2.852.85—REASONABLE
Gross value, $Volume × price35,340.0035,340.00—CONFIRMED
Transportation, $$0.10 per Mcf(1,240.00)(1,240.00)—PERMITTED
Gathering & compression, $$0.18 per Mcf(2,232.00)0.002,232.00QUESTIONABLE
Net value, $Gross less deductions31,868.0034,100.002,232.00—
Owner decimalDivision order0.003906250.00390625—MATCHES RECORD
Owner royalty, $Net value × decimal124.48133.208.72UNDERPAID

Volume, price and decimal reconcile. The gathering and compression deduction does not appear to be permitted by this lease, and it accounts for the full difference of $8.72 for the month, before severance taxes. Repeated across wells and years, an item of this kind is what a royalty review is built to find.

Reconciled to lease and recordException raised for follow-up
Our royalty review

How Warburg reviews royalty payments

Reconcile volumes

Compare reported volumes with production data available from state regulatory records. Where a state reports production by lease rather than by well, the comparison is made at that level.

Review pricing

Review reported prices for reasonableness against the product and the period, using available operator, public-record, regulatory and commercial data.

Apply the lease terms

Check that the royalty rate and the deduction treatment on each statement follow the governing lease.

Identify questionable deductions

Identify gathering, compression, processing, transportation and other deductions that appear inconsistent with the lease or with prior periods.

Confirm payment accuracy

Confirm the owner is paid at the correct decimal, on every well where the owner has an interest, on time. Identify wells that should be paying but are not.

Trace suspended balances

Identify wells and periods where revenue is held in suspense, determine the cause and assemble the documentation the operator requires. Recovery depends on each operator, each state and the owner's documentation, and is never guaranteed.

The deliverable

What the client receives

A reconciled payment record, built to be used. Each review produces a record the client keeps: what was paid, what the lease and the ownership record support, where the two differ, and what is being done about each difference.

  1. Reconciled royalty recordRoyalty income by operator, well and month.
  2. Schedule of exceptionsWhat was found, what appears owed, and the supporting documentation.
  3. Deduction reviewEach deduction set against the governing lease.
  4. Suspense scheduleEach held balance, its cause and what its release requires.
  5. Operator correspondence logEvery inquiry and response, organized by matter.
  6. Status of open mattersReported until closed, in regular portfolio reporting, including the Warburg Quarterly Review.
Schedule of exceptions · excerptILLUSTRATIVE · FICTIONAL DATA
OperatorWellPeriodExceptionStatus
Operator AUnit 1HJan⁠–⁠DecGathering deduction not supported by the leaseRAISED WITH OPERATOR
Operator AUnit 2HMayDecimal differs from the division orderRESOLVED · CORRECTED
Operator BUnit 3HApr⁠–⁠SepRevenue held after an owner's deathSUSPENSE · DOCUMENTS SENT
Operator CUnit 4HJul⁠–⁠SepNo payment received on a producing wellOPEN · INQUIRY

Each exception is supported by statement detail, the governing lease and the ownership record, and stays on the schedule until it is closed.

When Warburg manages a portfolio on an ongoing basis, the first review looks back across available history. After that, payments are reviewed each period and open matters are tracked to resolution.

Process

How the review is conducted

  1. 01

    Collect

    Warburg gathers operator check detail and revenue statements, division orders and the governing leases.

  2. 02

    Reconcile

    Payments are organized by operator, well and month and compared against expected decimals, production and lease terms.

  3. 03

    Identify

    Exceptions are documented: underpayments, unexplained deductions, suspense and missing wells.

  4. 04

    Follow up

    With the owner's authorization, Warburg raises each exception with the operator, provides the documentation it needs, and tracks the matter until it is resolved.

  5. 05

    Report

    Each matter's status appears in regular portfolio reporting, including the Warburg Quarterly Review, until it is closed.

When a review matters most

Payments are easiest to correct while the records are current.

  • When a well is sold or transferred to another operator
  • When payments stop, fall or change without explanation
  • When a new deduction appears on a statement
  • When an interest is inherited or moved into a trust
  • When a new well begins producing and first payments arrive
  • When revenue is shown as held in suspense
Scope of service

Where Warburg's role ends

Performed by Warburg

  • Reconciliation of statements against production, pricing and lease terms
  • Identification of underpayments, deductions and suspense
  • Follow-up with operators, with the owner's authorization
  • Documentation of each matter for the owner's advisers

Referred to the client's attorney or CPA

  • Formal disputes and legal remedies against an operator
  • Legal interpretation of lease deduction language
  • Financial statement audits and other accounting services
  • Tax treatment of royalty income and recovered amounts

Warburg is not an accounting firm, and a royalty review is not a financial statement audit. Where an operator disputes a material underpayment or deduction, the client's attorney decides whether to pursue formal remedies, and Warburg provides the documentation that decision requires.

Questions
How do I know whether my royalties are correct?
Only by checking them against the decimal you own, the volumes produced, the prices received and what your lease allows. That is the work this service does.
Why are my royalties in suspense?
Usually because the operator's ownership or contact records no longer match yours, because of a death, a move, an unsigned division order or an operator change. Funds held in suspense are often still owed, but they are not released until the operator receives what it needs.
Can Warburg get my missing money back?
Warburg can identify missing and suspended payments, document what is owed and follow up until each matter is resolved. Where funds have been transferred to a state unclaimed property program, Warburg can help locate and document the claim. The outcome depends on the operator, the state and the facts, and recovery is never guaranteed.
Related capabilities

Check the payments as carefully as the operator calculates them.

Payment errors are rarely deliberate and often small in any one month. A reconciled record shows what was paid, what the lease and the record support, and what remains open.

Request a Portfolio Review