Suspended royalties

Why is my royalty in suspense?

THE SHORT ANSWER

A royalty is in suspense when the payor, usually the operator, holds an owner's share of revenue instead of paying it, because its records cannot yet confirm who should be paid, in what share or where. Common causes are an undocumented death or transfer, a missing address or taxpayer ID, an unsigned division order or a title question.

The term

What "suspense" means

When a well produces, the company that pays the owners (the payor, usually the operator, sometimes the purchaser of the production) credits each owner's share of the revenue. If it cannot pay a particular owner, it records that owner's share in a suspense account and holds it.

Suspense is not a finding that the money is not owed. It usually means the payor's records are incomplete or in question: it is not sure who should be paid, in what share, or where to send the payment. The revenue keeps accruing while the question is open.

Causes

The common reasons a payment is held

Most suspense traces back to a record that no longer matches the owner's situation. The usual causes are:

  • A death or conveyance the payor has not documented. The interest has passed to heirs, a trust or a buyer, but the payor's record still shows the prior owner.
  • A transfer that is not recorded or probated. A deed was never filed in the county records, or a will was never probated, so the payor cannot confirm who now holds the interest.
  • A missing or wrong address. Checks come back undeliverable and the payor stops sending them.
  • A missing Form W-9 or taxpayer ID. Some payors hold payment until a completed W-9 is on file. Others pay but apply federal backup withholding, currently 24 percent, until they have a correct taxpayer identification number.
  • An unsigned division order. Some payors require a signed division order before paying. Texas law, for example, entitles a payor to receive one as a condition of payment.
  • A sale of the well. When a property changes operators, payment may pause while the new payor sets up its owner records.
  • A dispute or curative requirement. Competing claims to the interest, or a requirement in a title opinion that the owner supply documents to resolve a gap in title.
  • Small amounts. Payors commonly accumulate small balances and pay them less often than monthly. In Texas, for example, a payor that owes an owner $100 or less in total across all of its wells may pay that balance annually, and may hold very small balances longer. The statute also gives owners certain written-request rights, such as asking for annual payment of very small balances or monthly payment above a set amount. Other states set their own thresholds.
First steps

How to find out why a payment is held

The payor's owner relations department (sometimes called the revenue or division order department) is the place to ask. Contact details are usually printed on the check stub or revenue statement, or posted on the payor's website.

The owner's statements are the starting point. Many payors show held amounts, or a code for the reason, in statement detail. A payment that stops on one well while others continue usually points to a problem with that property; one that stops across all wells from the same payor usually points to the owner record itself, such as an address or tax form.

Useful to have at hand. The owner number the payor assigned, the owner name exactly as it appears on statements, the property or well name, and the date of the last payment received.
Resolution

What documents typically clear it

Each payor sets its own requirements, and what satisfies one may not satisfy another. In general terms, the document has to answer the question that caused the hold. Where the question is legal, such as who inherited an interest, the owner's attorney prepares or advises on the documents.

EXHIBIT 1

Suspense reasons, what usually resolves them, and who holds the information

General guidance. Requirements vary by payor, state and document.
Reason for suspenseWhat usually resolves itWho holds the information
Owner's deathDocuments showing who now holds the interest, such as probate records or an affidavit of heirship, as the payor requiresThe family and its attorney; the probate court; county records
Unrecorded transferA recorded copy of the deed or other conveyanceThe parties to the transfer; the county clerk once recorded
Address problemA signed change-of-address request in the form the payor acceptsThe owner
Missing W-9A completed Form W-9 with the correct taxpayer identification numberThe owner and the owner's tax adviser
Unsigned division orderA signed division order, after the owner has checked the decimal and descriptionThe payor's division order department; the owner
Well soldSet-up in the new payor's records, often with a new division order or transfer letterThe new payor; the prior payor's final statements
Title requirementThe curative documents the title opinion calls forThe payor's title examiner; the owner's attorney; county records
Below minimumNothing; the balance is paid once it reaches the payor's threshold or payment dateThe payor's statement detail

Illustrative only, not a specific owner's file. A payor may ask for more, or different, documents than shown here.

Over time

What happens if funds stay held for years

Interest. Many producing states set deadlines for paying royalty and provide for interest on late payments, with exceptions. In Texas, Natural Resources Code §91.402 sets the payment deadlines and §91.403 provides interest on late payments, but interest does not apply when a payor withholds payment for reasons the statute lists, such as a title dispute or an unanswered request for curative information. Whether interest is owed in a particular case is a question for the owner's attorney.

Unclaimed property. Every state has an unclaimed-property program. If held funds go unclaimed long enough, the payor may be required to report them to a state program. The period and the rules vary by state and by type of property. Funds reported to a state can generally still be claimed by the owner, and searching official state unclaimed-property sites is free.

Warburg's role

How Warburg's work relates

Under Royalty Audit & Management, Warburg reviews statements to identify payments that are held, documents the reason each payor gives, and follows up with the operator until the matter is closed or handed to the owner's attorney. Warburg does not give legal advice or title opinions, and it cannot promise that a payor will release funds. For the broader subject, see suspended royalties and division orders.

Questions

Does suspense mean I have lost the money?

No. Suspense means the payor is holding the funds, not that they are forfeited. They generally remain payable once the payor's requirement is met, and they remain claimable even if later reported to a state unclaimed-property program.

Should I sign a division order to get paid?

A division order states the owner's decimal interest and payment details. Before signing, an owner may want to check that the decimal and property description are correct. See what a division order is.

Will I be paid interest on held royalties?

It depends on the state, the lease and the reason for the hold. Some state statutes provide interest on late payments but exclude certain holds, such as those caused by title questions. The owner's attorney can advise on a specific case.

Sources

Sources and further reading

This article is general information, not legal, tax or accounting advice. Rules differ by state and by lease. Owners should consult their own attorney or tax adviser about their circumstances.

How Warburg helps

Know which payments are held, and why.

A portfolio review can identify payments held in suspense across payors and record what each payor says it needs.

Request a Portfolio Review