Division orders

What is a division order?

THE SHORT ANSWER

A division order is a document from the company that pays for oil and gas production. It states the owner's decimal interest in a well and the name, address and tax details used for payment. It is a payment instruction, not a deed: it does not transfer ownership, and in Texas it cannot change the lessee's obligations under the lease.

The document

What a division order is, and who sends it

A division order is a short document that tells the company paying for oil and gas production how to divide the money from a well among the people entitled to it. Each owner receives one showing that owner's share, expressed as a decimal, together with the name, address and taxpayer identification number the payor will use.

It is sent by the payor. That is often the operator of the well, which sells production and pays owners on behalf of everyone in it, but it can be the purchaser of the oil or gas. Texas law defines a payor by reference to the first purchaser of production unless other arrangements are made, and defines a division order as an agreement signed by the payee directing the distribution of proceeds.

Owners usually receive one when a new well begins producing, when wells are sold to a new operator, or when the payor's record of ownership changes.

Its effect

What a division order does, and what it does not do

A division order records the decimal and payee details so that the payor can pay. Many forms also ask the owner to certify that it owns the interest shown. Some forms add an agreement to notify the payor before the interest changes and to repay amounts received if the owner turns out not to hold the interest.

It is not a deed. Ownership of minerals passes by deed, will, probate or other recorded instruments, and a division order is not how that happens. A payor's decimal reflects its own review of title, which may or may not match the owner's records.

In Texas, Natural Resources Code §91.402(h) provides that signing a division order does not change or relieve the lessee's obligations under the oil and gas lease, including any obligation to market production as a reasonably prudent lessee, and that a division order provision contradicting the lease is invalid to the extent of the contradiction. Louisiana has a similar rule. Rules in other states vary, and the effect of a particular form is a question for the owner's attorney.

Reading one

What is on a division order, and what to check

Forms vary by company and state, but most include the items below. Each is worth comparing with the owner's own records.

  • Owner name and number. The name should match how the interest is actually held: an individual, a trust and its trustee, or an entity.
  • Property or well. The well name, the unit or lease, and the county. Confirm the owner has an interest in that land.
  • Type of interest. Royalty, overriding royalty or working interest. A royalty owner listed as anything else is worth asking about.
  • Decimal interest. The owner's share of production or proceeds from the well, usually to eight decimal places.
  • Effective date. The date from which the decimal applies.
  • Payment and tax details. Address, taxpayer identification number and, where offered, payment method.
  • Additional terms. Any provision about prices, deductions, indemnity or the lease beyond the basic payment terms.
The arithmetic

How an owner can check the decimal

For a royalty owner in a pooled unit whose production is shared by acreage, the decimal is usually the owner's net mineral acres in the unit, divided by the total acres in the unit, multiplied by the royalty fraction in the lease. Units that allocate production another way, such as some horizontal wells crossing several tracts, use different formulas, and the payor can explain the basis it used.

EXHIBIT 1

Checking a royalty decimal in a 640-acre unit

Illustrative · fictional data
StepCalculationResult
Net mineral acres in unitFrom the owner's deeds and the unit plat40.00
Unit acresFrom the unit designation640.00
Tract share40 ÷ 6400.06250000
Lease royalty1/4, from the lease0.25000000
Expected decimal0.0625 × 0.250.01562500
Decimal on division orderAs sent by the payor0.01171875
Difference0.01562500 − 0.01171875, or 25% lower0.00390625

The payor's figure equals 40 ÷ 640 × 3/16, or 30 ÷ 640 × 1/4. Either a royalty of 3/16 or 30 net mineral acres would produce it, so both the lease and the acreage are worth checking before asking the payor.

Signing

Whether and when to sign

Whether a payor may hold payment until a division order is signed depends on the state. In Texas, §91.402(c) lets a payor require a signed division order containing only listed provisions, among them the effective date, the property, the decimal interest and certification of title, authority to suspend payment during a title dispute, the payee's name, address and taxpayer number, and terms for valuing and timing payments. Under §91.402(e), if an owner refuses to sign one limited to those provisions, the payor may withhold payment without interest until it is signed. If the owner declines because the form adds other provisions, the statute generally does not allow the payor to withhold payment for that reason alone. How these provisions apply to a particular form, owner or payor depends on the facts and is a question for the owner's attorney.

Louisiana takes a different approach: its statute says signing a division order is not a condition of receiving royalty payments from the lessee.

In Texas, as a general rule, a division order is binding for the time and to the extent it has been acted on and made the basis of payments, and either party can end it on 30 days' written notice. That is one reason owners may want to check the decimal before returning the form.

Questions for an attorney. Whether to sign a particular form, whether its additional terms affect the owner's rights, and what a signature means for past payments are legal questions. Owners should consider asking their own attorney.
Discrepancies

What to do if the decimal looks wrong

  1. Recheck the inputs: the deeds or probate records behind the net mineral acres, the royalty fraction in the lease, and the unit acreage in the unit designation.
  2. Ask the payor's owner relations or division order department, in writing, how it calculated the decimal and what title it relied on.
  3. Send copies of the documents that support a different figure, and keep a record of what was sent and when.
  4. If the difference reflects a title question, such as an unrecorded conveyance or an heirship, the owner may want to involve an attorney.

Texas law also sets general deadlines for paying proceeds, in §91.402(a), subject to exceptions such as title disputes, and a written-notice process for nonpayment, which the Railroad Commission summarizes on its royalties page. Whether a particular payment is late, and what remedies may be available, depends on the facts and is a question for the owner's attorney. The Commission also notes that it cannot intervene in lease and royalty matters, including the payment of royalties.

Warburg's role

How Division Order Administration relates

Through Division Order Administration, Warburg can review a division order against the interest the record supports before it is returned, document any difference, and follow up with the payor until the question is answered. When the difference turns on title or a legal term, Warburg prepares the facts for the owner's attorney.

Questions

Why is my decimal different on each well?

Each well or unit has its own acreage, and sometimes its own lease. An owner with the same tract in two units of different sizes will have two different decimals.

Can a division order be changed after it is signed?

Yes. Payors issue new or corrected division orders when ownership or the unit changes, and in Texas either party can end a division order on 30 days' written notice. How a correction applies to past payments depends on the facts and the state.

Does signing a division order mean I agree with the deductions?

Not necessarily. In Texas, a division order cannot change the lessee's obligations under the lease. An owner who receives a form with added terms about pricing or deductions may want to ask an attorney about them before signing.

Sources

Sources and further reading

This article is general information, not legal, tax or accounting advice. Rules differ by state and by lease. Owners should consult their own attorney or tax adviser about their circumstances.

How Warburg helps

A decimal is easier to check before it is relied on.

A portfolio review can compare each division order with the ownership the record supports, and identify any figure that needs a closer look.

Request a Portfolio Review